Discovering Grove City Brewing Co. and Plum Run Winery on a Perfect Sunday Funday

I haven’t explored Grove City much in the past, but that changed when my dad moved to the area. I’ve discovered that Grove City has a lot of hidden gems, and I’ve been making an effort to explore more. Recently, my husband and I were house sitting for my dad, and we decided to visit one of the local breweries – Grove City Brewing Co. Even though I’m not a beer drinker, I love the atmosphere of breweries, and I was excited to check it out. I had heard that the brewery was somehow connected to a winery, but I wasn’t sure if it would be open on a Sunday. Fingers crossed, we headed over for a perfect Sunday Funday.

Look at that blue sky. It was gorgeous day.
As soon as we arrived at Grove City Brewing Co., I couldn’t help but notice their fantastic patio out front.
They had 10 or 11, 4 person tables – all covered by umbrellas.
We weren’t quite sure where the entrance was, so we ended up walking down what seemed like an alley. In retrospect, it’s hard to miss the huge garage door opening, but maybe we just wanted to take a peek at the winery first. Either way, we stumbled upon another great patio area, this one overlooking a parking lot, while the other faced a bustling intersection in the heart of downtown.
"Grove City Brewingโ€™s story begins with Plum Run Winery, opened by the Crosbys three years ago in the same building where the brewery is being built. Dave Crosby knew wines and ciders, but not beer. A mutual friend connected Crosby to Luther, an experienced home brewer who also was working at Buckeye Lake Brewery. Crosby and Burroughs work together on the Grove City Convention and Visitorโ€™s Bureau. She and Smolinski, her husband, own Hocking Hills Canopy Tours. Mantkowski, a friend, joined the group, too." - Dan Eaton, Biz Journals

Upon entering through the back entrance, which was not the main entrance, we arrived at the front bar where we were warmly welcomed by the staff. They patiently explained their offerings, which were plentiful and diverse. Although there were numerous options, I didn’t feel intimidated or overwhelmed. The TV screens on the wall display the beers on tap, including their signature beers and selections from other local breweries.

When trying out a new brewery or taproom, I always recommend starting with samples. Not only does it give you a chance to create the perfect flight of beers to try, but it also allows you to step outside your comfort zone and explore new flavors. If you’re unsure of what to try, don’t be afraid to ask the staff for recommendations. They know their beers inside and out and can suggest something that you may not have considered before. Plus, it’s always fun to try something new and unexpected!
We didn’t try this, but, pretty sure this is a way to ease me into liking beer. YUM!

As Stephen was perusing the beer options, I took a look at the menu to decide on some food. To my surprise, Stephen had already decided on what we were getting – the mozzarella-stuffed breadsticks, which we affectionately referred to as “BOSCO STICKS” due to their resemblance to a childhood favorite.

A significant improvement from the undercooked ones we enjoyed back in our elementary and high school days.
gimme all the cheese, please.

As a wine lover, my focus immediately shifted to exploring the history of the Plum Run Winery before I indulged in some wine tasting. It’s always exciting to learn about the background of a new place, and it’s something I make sure to do before visiting. Understanding the story behind a business, especially one where people are following their dreams and pursuing their passions, is always inspiring to me. I want to know what motivates them, what their aspirations are, and how they go about achieving them. Simply scratching the surface with small talk is not enough for me – I want to dive deeper. So, after reading about the winery’s history, I was ready to explore and experience everything Plum Run had to offer.

Anyways, back on track. The story behind Plum Winery and the owners, Dave and Diane Crosby, is a fun one. An inspiring one.

"Plum Run Vineyard and Winery is named from the small stream of the same name that originates on our farm south of Grove City, Ohio. Our Vineyard consists of three acres of grapes that include Traminette, Vidal, Chambourcin and Cabernet Franc. A total of 16 varieties of grapes are planted on the farm. Grapes from Plum Run Vineyard as well as grapes sourced from other Ohio vineyards are used to craft a variety of fine wines for your purchase."

They tell their story much better than I would – you an read it here. They weren’t in when we were there, but, I would love to go back and chat with them. Maybe visit their winery and share stories about our failures at making wine at home.

This is the stating room in the back. Ya know, the one I walked into first (at the back of the room). Why wouldn’t I just go in the front? Lol. At least, I got to see this room! We were there right when they opened – so, it was pretty quiet in the back.
I went with a flight, of course. It is a great way to sample the different wines that the winery has. Plus, each “sample” is $1. Yeah, $1. I should have tried them ALL!
As a red wine enthusiast, I tend to gravitate towards bold and dry reds, but don’t let my preference deceive you. On this visit to Grove City Brewing Co. and Plum Run Winery, I was pleasantly surprised by the Scioto Red – a sweet red wine made from a blend of Concord and Niagara grapes. With its light, fruity, and very aromatic notes, it had a sweetness level of 4% Residual Sugar, making it my husband’s favorite. Although I typically don’t enjoy sweet reds, I found myself really enjoying this one.

Once we finished our wine flight, we ventured out to the patio to enjoy the great weather and order more food. However, before we could dive into the menu, I had to pick out a board game. To my surprise, they had a great selection of games to choose from!

They have a pretty good variety of games. Perfect for a two-person couple and a big group.
Stephen and I are pretty competitive. When it comes to yahtzee, it’s another level. He never wins. Until this day. He smoked me!
I also chose UNO. Not because I always win, but, because I love UNO. Well, just like yahtzee, I LOST! Dang. He was on a roll that day.
This was basically my hand the entire time. No wonder I lost.
Drowning my sorrows in a very delicious wine slushy! YUM!

As we sat on the patio and played our board game, we couldn’t resist ordering more food. The Broadway burger caught our eye with its tempting toppings, including the irresistible bacon jam. Of course, we couldn’t pass up on a side of fries to go with it.

Look at that char on that bun. NOMS.
The burger was decent, but it didn’t quite hit the mark for me. I was hoping for a stronger taste of the bacon jam.
Let’s switch gears and talk about something truly amazing – the seasoned housemade fries. These fries were out of this world! You know that feeling when you just can’t stop eating something because it’s so delicious? That’s exactly how we felt about these fries. They were seasoned to perfection and we couldn’t get enough of them!
I came across a photo of their pretzel on Facebook after we left and instantly regretted not ordering it. The picture gave me a sense of scale, and it looked huge! I’m definitely going to make a note to come back soon and give it a try.

I must admit that I do have one negative comment to make – why isn’t this place closer to our home? (laughs) Jokes apart, this has become one of my favorite spots. The ambiance, the enthusiasm, the staff, the beer, the wine, the patios, the customers – everything was just perfect. If we didn’t have to rush back to our three adorable puppies, I would have loved to spend the entire afternoon there.


Plum Winery + Grove City Brewing Company

3946 Broadway Grove City, Ohio 43123

They are located in the heart of the Grove City Ohio Town Center at the corner of Broadway (Rt. 62 and 3) and Columbus Street. Parking can be found onsite (Columbus Street side) or across the street in City Publicย Parking.

Website | Facebookย 


Discover more from Eat Play CBUS

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.