A Throwback to Childhood Tea Parties: A Visit to Asterisk in Westerville

As a child of the mid-80s, mini-tea sets were all the rage. And while tea itself may not be my cup of tea, tea parties with mini-sandwiches and other treats were definitely a favorite pastime. Lucky for me, I discovered a spot just blocks away from my home in Westerville, Ohio that offers a daily tea party.

Asterisk, located in Uptown Westerville, has quickly become one of my favorite places to visit. The restaurant has a charming atmosphere that transports you back to a time when friends and neighbors gathered around the supper table to share a meal. The floor-to-ceiling bookshelves, antique chandeliers, and beautiful hand-carved Brunswick 1890 bar all add to the throwback ambiance of the place.

Asterisk’s owner, Megan Ada, wanted to pay tribute to the rich history of Westerville when she came up with the concept for the restaurant. Westerville was known as the “Dry Capitol of the World” during the years of prohibition, and even though prohibition ended in 1933, the town remained dry until 2006. Ada sought to capture the slower pace of life when neighbors would come together to share meals and conversation.

The menu at Asterisk features comfort food and classic cocktails, with the tea party being a standout. Whether you’re a fan of tea or just love the nostalgia of childhood tea parties, Asterisk’s daily tea time is a must-try. And if you’re looking for a quick drink or group dinner, Asterisk has options for those as well.

Their style exudes warmth and comfort with vintage touches that make you feel right at home.

How stunning is their space! No need to worry about cobwebs, they’re just for Halloween.

Obsessed with the chandeliers.

I adore the vintage glassware and books – such a lovely touch!

Blurry pic, was trying not to bother the table close by! This table runs down the middle and while you can bring a large group, it’s also fun to sit with “strangers” who become friends!

My sister and I have visited Asterisk several times, but our most recent visit was for their afternoon tea. Although I’m not a tea drinker, I can’t resist mini-sandwiches (or anything miniature for that matter). Afternoon tea is offered daily from 12pm to 4pm, with options for petite tea, full tea, or ร€ la carte.

Now. Here comes my favorite part – the sandwiches.

A helpful tip: We highly recommend ordering all of the sandwiches, just like we did!”

BLT – featuring bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo – and Cucumber Sandwich – consisting of cucumber, cream cheese, and dill.

egg salad sandwich: pepper, radish sprout

The strawberry sandwich is made with honey, cream cheese, and raisin bread.

Their kitchen produces a delightful variety of desserts every day.

brown sugar and cinnamon scone served with real clotted cream
lemon blueberry scone

For me, Asterisk has become a place to relive childhood memories while also experiencing a bit of Westerville’s history. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Asterisk is definitely worth a visit.

Asterisk Supper Club

14 North State Street
Westerville, OH 43081
614-776-4633
Instagram | Facebookย 

ย 

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSave


Discover more from Eat Play CBUS

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.